WATCH: How Jimmy Fallon Blew His Chance to Date Nicole Kidman

Ah, the one that got away. We all have one. For Tonight Show host Jimmy Fallon, that’s Nicole Kidman, although no one really knew it — not even Fallon himself.

On last night’s episode, guest Nicole Kidman related the time the two of them first met. The beautiful Nicole Kidman was somehow interested in goofy ol’ Jimmy Fallon, but he was way too oblivious to notice it. This revelation of course shocked Fallon, and his reaction is a delight to watch.

The story is mainly contained in the first half of the video below.